Amid the rising buzz round Ozempic and comparable weight-loss medicine, a bunch of 58 researchers is difficult the best way weight problems is outlined and identified, arguing that present strategies fail to seize the complexity of the situation. They provide a extra nuanced strategy.
The group’s revised definition, revealed in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology on 14 January, focuses on how extra physique fats, a measure known as adiposity, impacts the physique, fairly than relying solely on physique mass index (BMI), which hyperlinks an individual’s weight to their peak. They suggest two classes: preclinical weight problems, when an individual has further physique fats however their organs work usually, and medical weight problems, when extra fats harms the physique’s organs and tissues.
This shift may enhance medical care, public-health insurance policies and societal attitudes towards weight problems, says Elisabeth van Rossum, an endocrinologist on the Erasmus College Medical Middle Rotterdam within the Netherlands.
On supporting science journalism
In case you’re having fun with this text, think about supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By buying a subscription you might be serving to to make sure the way forward for impactful tales concerning the discoveries and concepts shaping our world right now.
“Now the thought is, eat much less, transfer extra, and also you’ll drop some pounds,” says van Rossum, who wasn’t concerned within the work. Though a wholesome life-style is necessary, she provides, “if it might be so easy, we wouldn’t have an epidemic, and this paper is a wonderful contribution to the dialogue concerning the complexity of weight problems”.
International downside
Greater than 1 billion folks worldwide dwell with weight problems, and the situation is linked to about 5 million deaths yearly from issues corresponding to diabetes and heart problems.
As a result of it’s straightforward to measure and examine, BMI has lengthy been used as a device to diagnose weight problems. However it doesn’t provide a full image of an individual’s well being, as a result of it doesn’t account for variations in physique composition, corresponding to muscle versus fats.
For folks of European descent, weight problems is often outlined by a BMI of 30 or larger, which correlates with a excessive degree of physique fats. Nonetheless, a muscular athlete could be labelled overweight on the premise of BMI, whereas somebody with a ‘regular’ BMI may need extra fats that will increase their danger of coronary heart issues or different severe well being points, says Francesco Rubino, a bariatric surgeon at King’s School London, who led the group proposing the brand new strategy.
Standard strategies result in pointless therapy for some folks whereas lacking others who need assistance, he says. To handle this, Rubino and his colleagues suggest a system for diagnosing weight problems that goes past BMI, combining it with different strategies corresponding to measuring waist circumference, which is a proxy for adiposity, or physique scans utilizing low-level X-rays, which may straight measure fats mass.
Though there isn’t a hard and fast threshold for weight problems, physique fats is often thought-about to be in extra when it’s above 25% in males and 30–38% in ladies. As a result of measuring adiposity straight could be impractical or pricey, various well being markers corresponding to waist measurement, waist-to-hip ratio or waist-to-height ratio are necessary, the researchers say. Nonetheless, they add, it’s secure to imagine that an individual with a BMI above 40 has excessive physique fats.
Diagnosing weight problems also needs to think about the outcomes of normal laboratory exams, medical historical past, and knowledge on day by day actions to evaluate how extra physique fats would possibly have an effect on an individual’s well being, says examine co-author Robert Eckel, an endocrinologist on the College of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus in Aurora. “These are goal diagnostic standards, they’re standardized throughout world well being methods,” he says.
Customized assessments that think about age, gender and ethnicity are equally necessary, as a result of sure teams would possibly face well being dangers at decrease BMI thresholds than others, says examine co-author Louise Baur, a paediatrician on the College of Sydney, Australia.
Two classes
Though folks with preclinical weight problems have tissues that work usually, they’re at a better danger of creating well being issues than are folks with out weight problems. They’ll profit from counselling and preventive measures corresponding to life-style modifications to scale back their danger of creating extra severe well being points, the group says.
Scientific weight problems happens when extra fats harms organs or it critically limits day by day actions corresponding to strolling or getting dressed. Individuals with medical weight problems would possibly require remedies geared toward bettering well being and stopping issues.
Rubino notes that this strategy is particularly necessary with the rising use of weight-loss medicine, as a result of it helps to supply extra correct diagnoses and make therapy efficient and cost-efficient.
Stigma problem
The strategy, which has been supported by dozens of scientific and patient-advocacy teams worldwide, displays growing proof of weight problems’s results on well being, van Rossum says. One other framework, revealed final yr, additionally acknowledged that the weight problems analysis ought to transcend BMI to incorporate an evaluation of its impacts on well being.
Nonetheless, many health-care suppliers nonetheless see weight problems as a problem of willpower fairly than a illness pushed by extra fats, no matter its underlying causes — which can embrace hormonal modifications and genetic components, van Rossum says. Within the Netherlands, for instance, a examine she co-authored discovered that most individuals with weight problems had skilled stigma in a health-care setting. This stigma typically prevents folks from searching for care, highlighting the necessity for higher training and communication concerning the situation.
Though the newest strategy goals to present a extra correct image of weight problems, it’s unclear whether or not it’ll result in extra or fewer diagnoses, or the way it will have an effect on administration of the situation within the clinic. “With time, we hope that this form of evaluation can be included in medical apply tips,” Baur says.
This text is reproduced with permission and was first revealed on January 14, 2025.