Bronx Sidewalk Clam Heaven | The New Yorker

Photo of author

By Calvin S. Nelson

A selected restaurant, a particular market, an beautiful sandwich—no matter it’s that brings you to Arthur Avenue, a two-block stretch at East 187th Avenue, within the heart of the Bronx that’s well-known for being the borough’s Little Italy, the true draw is all the space. It’s ill-advised, if not downright inconceivable, to do a fast in-and-out at one enterprise solely, to disregard the wealth of food and drinks that surrounds you. Perhaps you are available for scarpariello at Dominick’s or scaloppine at Mario’s, or a bouquet of sausages from Calabria Pork Retailer, however it could be a wasted alternative to not swing by Morrone Pastry for a field of Florentines, or to choose up an Alla Phil on ciabatta at Casa Della Mozzarella for lunch.

Crabs on show at Cosenza’s Fish Market, down the block and throughout the road from Randazzo’s.

To my thoughts, no journey to the realm is full and not using a pit cease at one of many road’s duelling out of doors shellfish stands—particularly within the autumn, when the air is just a bit too chilly, and being open air looks like a deal with. The 2 ersatz uncooked bars, one outdoors Cosenza’s Fish Market, on the east aspect of Arthur Avenue, the opposite outdoors Randazzo’s Seafood, throughout the road and somewhat down the block, are the place you will get varied shellfish shucked to order, devouring them à la minute whereas standing round on the sidewalk. There’s one thing unavoidably primal about prying open an oyster or clam and sucking it from its shell—there’s no option to aesthetically refine the act’s important ferality. All the same old intermediations of human carnivorousness are absent: no slaughter, no butchering, no cooking. It’s enjoyable as hell, a disposal of formality, a second of pure sensation. A white-haired gent in a topcoat and fedora throws down a dozen clams shoulder to shoulder with a twentysomething style girly in platform sneakers, an eleven-year-old boy in a camo jacket, and a middle-aged meals author: We’re animals consuming animals, in the midst of the road, within the Bronx.

Folks maintain fierce loyalties to their Arthur Avenue shops of selection, largely based mostly on nostalgia, and the indefinable worth of a private relationship with one’s foodmonger. I gained’t let you know that Cosenza’s or Randazzo’s is healthier—the reality is, you will get a stunning little bit of salmon or a wiggly pile of recent scungilli at each. Each have been in operation for the reason that early nineteen-hundreds; each have an environment of brisk effectivity; each draw passionate crowds to the pelagic wonders on the market inside and to the wondrously zero-frills uncooked bars with out. At Cosenza’s, ice-filled benches simply outdoors the shop’s home windows show piles of bivalves: clams are shucked to the left of the entrance door (a buck-fifty every for juicy midsize cherrystones, fifteen {dollars} for a dozen) and oysters to the correct. On a current go to, the lineup included Beau Soleils, from New Brunswick, and Wellfleets, from Massachusetts, for $2.99 every; Blue Factors from Lengthy Island Sound, for $2.50; and—at a steep $3.99 a pop—Kumamotos from California’s Humboldt Bay. There’s an array of dressings and scorching sauces, together with a mouth-puckering selfmade mignonette, and the oysters are wonderful, a symphony of brine and richness, particularly the Blue Factors, gentle and wealthy as salted butter, and the peachy sweetness of the Kumamotos. However I struggled to get previous the restaurant-level pricing. The stand-and-slurp expertise was transportive, transcendent; handing over my bank card was a thunking return to earth.

The storefront of Randazzos Seafood.

Slurping shellfish alfresco is a specific deal with in autumn, when the air is just a bit too chilly.

Down the block and throughout the road, at Randazzo’s (no business relation to the restaurant of the identical identify in Sheepshead Bay, although the proprietors are distant cousins), the sidewalk uncooked bar affords an analogous proposition, with somewhat bit extra of a rough-spun air. The day’s choices are stored on ice simply outdoors the store—however saved in a cooler, right here, relatively than neatly arrayed for show—and there’s a stainless-steel countertop to stomach as much as, relatively than, as at Cosenza’s, a branded vinyl marquee. There have been clams, after all, fifteen {dollars} a dozen, and likewise the thrilling possibility of razor clams, their lengthy, rectangular shells housing juicy mollusks extra delicate in taste than their typical counterparts. There have been simply two forms of oyster on supply—Blue Factors, with their tangy liquor and grassy, brilliant taste, and people buttery Beau Soleil—every at two {dollars} apiece. That’s the kind of worth that lets an individual order a dozen, and perhaps one other dozen after that, to see how far she will be able to take this factor. As at Cosenza’s, you possibly can stand on the counter and slurp them as they’re shucked or, fairly enticingly, sit down at one of many folding chairs set on the sidewalk towards the opposite shopwindow, to people-watch, and maybe sip on a budget white wine in somewhat plastic cup that’s mysteriously appeared on the cardboard desk in entrance of you. Squeeze the lemon, dab the new sauce, devour. ♦

Leave a Comment