“Dune” and the Delicate Artwork of Making Fictional Languages

Photo of author

By Calvin S. Nelson

A trailer for Denis Villeneuve’s “Dune: Half Two” options the boy prophet Paul Atreides, performed by Timothée Chalamet, yelling one thing overseas and uninterpretable to a horde of desert folks. We see Chalamet because the embodiment of charismatic fury: each facial muscle clenched in rigidity, his voice strained and throaty and commanding. A line on the backside of the display screen interprets: “Lengthy stay the fighters!”

The scene fills barely just a few seconds in a three-minute trailer, but it establishes the emotional tone of the movie and captures the messianic fervor that drives its plot. It additionally indicators the depth of Villeneuve’s world-building. A part of what made his first tour into the “Dune” universe such an experiential feast was its vivid, immersive high quality, combining monumental architectural design with atmospheric soundscapes and ethereal costuming. We may see just a few remnants of our world (bear in mind the bit with the bagpipes?), however the over-all impact was transportive, as if the digital camera weren’t a chunk of apparatus however a cyborgian eye live-streaming from a far-flung alien civilization. Chalamet’s unusual tongue is a part of the franchise’s meticulous set dressing. It’s not gibberish, however a part of an intricate linguistic system that was devised for Villeneuve’s variations.

Engineered languages such because the one Chalamet speaks symbolize a brand new benchmark in imaginative fiction. Twenty years in the past, viewers would have struggled to call franchises aside from “Star Trek” or “The Lord of the Rings” that bothered to invent new languages. Right now, with the budgets of the largest movies and collection rivalling the G.D.P.s of small island nations, constructed languages, or conlangs, have gotten a norm, if not an implicit requirement. Breeze by means of leisure from the previous decade or so, and also you’ll discover lingos designed for Paleolithic peoples (“Alpha”), spell-casting witches (“Penny Dreadful”), post-apocalyptic survivors (“Into the Badlands”), Superman’s dwelling planet of Krypton (“Man of Metal”), a cross-species alien alliance (“Halo”), time-travelling preteens (“Paper Ladies”), the Munja’kin tribe of Oz (“Emerald Metropolis”), and Santa Claus and his elves (“The Christmas Chronicles” and its sequel).

A well-executed conlang can bolster a movie’s look of authenticity. It may deepen the scenic absorption that has lengthy been an obsession for creators and followers of speculative genres similar to science fiction and fantasy. However the leisure trade’s fixation with crafting super-realistic realms can be distracting. Speculative fiction works by melding the aware of the unrecognizable. It makes trenchant provocations not by creating essentially the most believably alien worlds doable however by interweaving them with strands from our personal.

Hollywood’s present obsession with constructed languages arguably began with “The Lord of the Rings” movie variations of the early two-thousands. J. R. R. Tolkien was a professor of Previous English at Oxford and a lifelong conlanger, and he famously created the tongues of Center-earth lengthy earlier than writing the books. “The invention of languages is the inspiration,” he as soon as wrote. “The ‘tales’ have been made fairly to offer a world for the languages than the reverse.” The trilogy’s success confirmed the facility of conlangs to create engrossing alternate realities, inspiring filmmakers to hunt out expert language creators.

Essentially the most influential conlanger working at the moment is David J. Peterson. Born in Lengthy Seashore, California, Peterson began to create languages in 2000, whereas he was a sophomore at U.C. Berkeley. His early initiatives have been amusing experiments: X, a language that might solely be written; Sheli, which included solely sounds that he appreciated and was initially unpronounceable; and Zhyler, which he created as a result of he loved Turkish and which, in honor of the Heinz Firm, had fifty-seven noun instances. In 2005, he graduated with a grasp’s diploma in linguistics from U.C. San Diego. Two years later, he co-founded the Language Creation Society with 9 different conlangers.

Peterson’s massive break got here in 2009, when HBO reached out to the Language Creation Society with an odd request. They have been making a tv present (which might turn into “Recreation of Thrones”) and needed somebody to develop a language (which might emerge as Dothraki). Nothing like this had ever occurred earlier than, so the society organized a contest that may be judged by the present’s producers. After signing a nondisclosure settlement, candidates have been invited to ship in a phonetic breakdown of Dothraki, a romanized transcription system, six to eight strains of translated textual content, and any extra notes or translations.

Peterson had an edge over his opponents: unemployment. For 2 and a half weeks, he labored eighteen-hour days, assembling 100 and eighty pages of fabric. He made it to the second spherical and finally produced greater than 300 pages in Dothraki. He landed the job and was later invited to develop 5 extra languages for the collection, together with Excessive Valyrian, which proved particularly common amongst followers. In 2017, a Excessive Valyrian course launched on the language-learning app Duolingo; at one level in 2023, greater than 9 hundred thousand folks had signed up as lively customers.

Together with James Cameron’s “Avatar” (2009), which appeared in theatres quickly after Peterson was employed by HBO, the primary season of “Recreation of Thrones” demonstrated that audiences not solely tolerated fictional languages—they liked them. What had beforehand been a nerdy pastime reworked into a regular of fantasy filmmaking. Peterson turned the go-to language wizard. He has since been employed to create some fifty different conlangs, together with languages for the Darkish Elves in “Thor: The Darkish World” (2013), for the Grounders within the tv present “The 100” (2014-20), and for the desert-dwelling Fremen within the two “Dune” motion pictures. When Chalamet, as Paul Atreides, calls to his combatants, he does so in phrases devised by Peterson and his spouse and fellow-conlanger, Jessie. (Peterson labored alone for the primary “Dune” movie, and collaborated together with her on the second.)

Peterson’s success stems from a dedication to naturalism. He is aware of languages properly; he has studied greater than twenty, together with Swahili, Center Egyptian, and Esperanto, and appears to have an infinite psychological Rolodex of the lexical, grammatical, and phonological patterns discovered all over the world. But, when an interviewer requested him how, when assembling a brand new conlang, he decides “which features of a language to borrow from and mimic” (Greek suffixes? Mongolian tenses? Japanese particles?), he rejected the premise. “In case you simply ripped out a construction from one language and put it in your individual, the consequence can be inauthentic,” he replied.

Peterson’s concept of authenticity generally places him at odds together with his supply texts. When creating Excessive Valyrian, Peterson was compelled to incorporate phrases that George R. R. Martin had composed for the books, together with dracarys, that means “dragon fireplace.” The phrase was clearly impressed by the Latin draco, that means “dragon,” a choice that Peterson discovered “unlucky.” “Within the universe of the books, there isn’t any such factor because the Latin language—or any of the opposite languages on Earth,” he as soon as wrote. “It’s actually unimaginable for any phrase (or anything) within the Music of Ice and Fireplace universe to be associated to something in our universe.” Because of this, he made dracarys its personal root and selected zaldrīzes because the phrase for “dragon,” frightening a string of upset feedback from “Recreation of Thrones” followers on his weblog.

As Peterson specified by his 2015 ebook, “The Artwork of Language Invention,” he treats languages as evolving methods whose options are interconnected and formed by a singular historical past. To design verbs in Excessive Valyrian, for instance, he simulated a four-stage evolution from a prehistoric type. Within the model of Excessive Valyrian spoken in “Recreation of Thrones,” verbs have an imperfect stem (for previous actions that have been steady or incomplete) and an ideal stem (for previous actions that have been accomplished). The proper stem, he determined, was shaped in historic instances by appending -tat­ to the tip of the imperfect. Over time, this turned -tet after which -et, which frequently reduces to -t within the model spoken within the tv present. (Throughout that imagined historical past, -tat additionally gave rise to the verb tatagon, that means “to complete.”) There are numerous different intricacies to Excessive Valyrian verbs, but, for Peterson, even producing this lone grammatical function required simulating generations of linguistic change.

When he was invited to work on “Dune,” Peterson fell again on the strategies he had honed for earlier initiatives. “Within the case of each Dune and Recreation of Thrones,” he wrote throughout an Ask Me Something on Reddit earlier than Half One’s launch, “there was some minimal language components from the books that I needed to account for, however aside from that it was as much as me to create one thing model new.” He had determined, in different phrases, to develop what conlangers name an a-priori language—one whose vocabulary and grammar are wholly authentic, and never derived from an current linguistic system.

Creating one thing new might need made sense for different initiatives, however, as followers will certainly inform you, language features in another way in “Dune.” Written by Frank Herbert, and initially revealed in 1965, the novel recounts how noble homes compete to regulate the desert planet Arrakis (the eponymous Dune), the one supply of essentially the most valuable substance within the universe. The story entwines the destiny of the aristocratic Paul Atreides with the indigenous Fremen, whose harsh desert life fashion and non secular prophecies set the scene for ecological challenges and epic political face-offs.

Herbert’s “Dune” takes place unimaginably far sooner or later. The time span separating us from the occasions of “Dune” is roughly twice the gap between us and the tip of the Ice Age; sabre-toothed tigers are nearer to us than the plot of “Dune” is. Nonetheless, it’s a world suffused with acquainted echoes, most of which manifest in language. The novel options phrases derived from French (“verite”), Turkish (“kanly”), Hebrew (“Kwisatz Haderach”), German (“schlag”), and Navajo (“Nezhoni”). Having been raised in a Sikh family, I bear in mind noticing the emperor’s title, Padishah, a Persian time period that has been used as an honorific for rulers in North Africa, the Center East, and South Asia. Sikhs use it to consult with God and the ten prophet leaders, or gurus.

Leave a Comment