How Diamond Shoppers Can Keep away from the Risks of Greenwashing

Photo of author

By Calvin S. Nelson

Left picture: laboratory grown diamond manufacturing facility in China; proper picture: unpolished laboratory grown diamonds

The overwhelming majority of U.S. customers say a sustainable way of life issues to them. And so they again that up with what they purchase. Sixty p.c of customers in a latest McKinsey survey mentioned they might pay extra for merchandise with sustainable packaging; for millennials and Gen Zs, the proportion is even increased.

A steep value of going inexperienced is “greenwashing”: manufacturers utilizing misinformation or unhealthy information to mislead customers about their environmentalism. Organizations that resort to greenwashing danger reputational injury amongst clients who’ve paid a premium for what has turned out to be a false sense of sustainability, actually shopping for into environmentalist myths.

Manufacturers fight greenwashing with transparency, offering dependable third-party-verified certification and audited information to measure their affect, sourcing, manufacturing, and distribution, in addition to to create a dependable future technique to enhance it. Sadly, some organizations that withhold such data should benefit from the halo impact of their sector’s sustainable public picture.

The Quick Vogue of Laboratory Grown Diamonds

Diamonds are a cherished and enduring image of affection and dedication, which makes them a well-liked funding. As with every vital buy, it’s essential for customers to analysis earlier than shopping for, together with the selection between laboratory grown and naturally sourced diamonds.

Given the excessive monetary and emotional prices, it’s important for diamond manufacturers to assist customers discern between what’s inexperienced and what’s greenwashing. And laboratory grown diamonds might not all be as environmentally or socially pleasant as they appear.

It’s unattainable to characterize the class of laboratory grown diamonds as having an general impartial or optimistic environmental affect. With out affect information transparency, not one of the laboratory grown diamond producers ought to make claims of sustainable practices.

Any misperception that laboratory grown diamonds are typically extra sustainable than naturally sourced diamonds might be expensive—each to the planet and to customers’ wallets.

The laboratory grown diamond sector bears similarities to the quick style {industry}, whose cheap, mass-produced, quickly depreciating kinds might conceal resource-intensive manufacturing prices. Like quick style, laboratory grown diamonds might be made in weeks, and even days, and in limitless portions—in distinction to pure diamonds, a product in finite provide that takes billions of years to type.

A typical argument for selecting laboratory grown diamonds is that they’re practically indistinguishable from pure diamonds. However verification instruments can simply detect the variations in development patterns between pure diamonds that shaped deep inside Earth 1 billion to three billion years in the past and artificial diamonds that had been manufactured in underneath two weeks. The power to distinguish these patterns and their sourcing processes makes laboratory grown diamond costs far decrease.

Most natural-diamond mining firms are publicly listed and report on the numerous measures they take to make sure their uncommon gems are ethically sourced, extra environmentally pleasant, and conflict-free, and that they profit the households, communities, and international locations of those that supply them. (The natural-diamond sector helps over 10 million folks worldwide.) Such transparency helps customers think about which product finest aligns with their sustainability consciousness.

Fossil Fuels and Carbon Emissions

Many customers assume laboratory grown diamonds are sustainably produced as a result of they don’t contain mining. However that’s a false impression: the high-pressure, high-temperature methodology of producing makes use of graphite, and the chemical vapor deposition methodology makes use of high-purity methane sourced from gasoline, coal, and oil drilling. Laboratory grown diamonds’ manufacturing equipment can also be constructed with mined metals.

Massive-scale pure diamond producers corresponding to De Beers Group are dedicated to changing into carbon impartial by 2030, and mining large Rio Tinto has set the objective of attaining net-zero emissions by 2050, incorporating renewable and various gasoline sources into mining operations and exploring artificial fuels and biofuels. The Diavik mine in Canada’s Northwest Territories makes use of wind turbine power for a good portion of its operations, making it a world chief in cold-climate know-how.

Pure-diamond firms are additionally researching revolutionary strategies for absorbing carbon, corresponding to by means of the mineralization of the kimberlite rock from which diamonds are recovered.

Opening a mine requires not less than 10 years of cautious planning among the many natural-diamond firms and the native governments and communities. Earlier than a single diamond is recovered, governments should grant environmental permissions with a authorized obligation for ongoing monitoring, affect mitigation, and reporting, together with on post-mining land use, plans to assist the prosperity of communities, and closure plans and land rehabilitation on the finish of the mine’s productive life. That is very important to make sure native communities and companies will proceed to thrive past the mine’s operation.

Greenwashing vs. Regulation

The worldwide crackdown on greenwashing has already taken maintain throughout key markets for diamond jewellery. The U.S. Federal Commerce Fee (FTC) warns synthetic-diamond firms that it may sanction any campaigns that declare merchandise are “eco-friendly,” “eco-conscious,” or “sustainable” with out particular proof. The FTC additionally intends to bolster its Inexperienced Guides, which assist entrepreneurs keep away from making deceptive environmental claims.

Member firms of the Pure Diamond Council should adjust to worldwide and environmental laws, and any practices together with provenance claims have to be audited by means of such third-party certifications as that of the Accountable Jewelry Council.

Social Sustainability and Moral Sourcing

Governments, mining firms, and nongovernmental organizations are all stakeholders in a wholesome and affluent diamond {industry}. These stakeholders collectively be sure that all constituents share prosperity and place the well being and well-being of staff and their communities on the forefront of all key selections. Native communities can retain as much as 80% of the worth of tough diamonds from these actions in addition to taxes, royalties, and different income.

Below the Kimberley Course of mandated by the United Nations and the World Commerce Group, all rough-diamond commerce is strictly regulated to make sure it’s conflict-free. The Kimberley Course of Certification Scheme has been basic to attaining conflict-free commerce as a joint initiative amongst governments, diamond-industry our bodies, and civil society since 2003.

The heavy oversight of the natural-diamond {industry} stands in stark distinction to that of laboratory grown diamonds. An absence of regulatory oversight or tangible information transparency in China and India, the 2 largest producers within the rising laboratory grown sector, makes it tough for governments or {industry} associations—to not point out customers—to study factories or sources from the businesses that produce laboratory grown diamonds.

And for sustainability-minded diamond customers, that’s one of many risks of greenwashing: verifying claims of laboratory grown producers’ sustainable practices is almost unattainable.

The True Price of Diamonds

Very like that of quick style attire, the value of laboratory grown diamonds displays the amount and high quality of manufacturing—costing much less up entrance and dropping their worth accordingly. Costs for some 1.5-carat laboratory grown diamonds have fallen by greater than 74% between 2016 and 2023: a client who spent $10,600 for a laboratory grown diamond in 2016 may have purchased the identical stone seven years later for $2,445. Whereas the value of pure diamonds fluctuates, costs have risen over the previous 35 years by a mean of three% yearly.

The pricing constructions of laboratory grown and pure diamonds additionally differ. The provision, dimension, and accessible high quality mixture of pure diamonds rely upon geology. As a result of giant stones are very uncommon, a 2-carat pure stone might value triple the value of a 1-carat pure stone. For laboratory grown diamonds, the principle constraint is every firm’s manufacturing capability, so the value improve by carat is linear.

When evaluating the prices of diamonds, customers should think about the entire image. Offering customers with data transparently will enable them to make extra knowledgeable selections relating to diamonds that actually align with their values.

Go to the Pure Diamond Council to match {industry} myths and info at

Leave a Comment