Novak Djokovic’s knee harm and French Open withdrawal: What it means

Photo of author

By Calvin S. Nelson

Observe dwell protection of the 2024 French Open right this moment

The information that Novak Djokovic has withdrawn from the French Open with a torn meniscus was a kind of moments at Roland Garros the place the gasps have been audible.

It wasn’t an enormous shock given Djokovic mentioned he was uncertain if he would play his quarterfinal after selecting up the harm in a fourth-round win over Francisco Cerundolo. Nonetheless, to lose the world No. 1 and defending champion on this method is big.

However what are the implications of Djokovic’s withdrawal — for him, the occasion, and the game generally?

What it means for Novak Djokovic

What’s Djokovic’s harm?

Djokovic withdrew from the French Open on Tuesday with a tear within the medial meniscus of his proper knee. The meniscus is a semicircle of cartilage that sits on the within half of the knee joint. It’s an especially widespread harm amongst lively adults, particularly middle-aged males, and might deliver various quantities of ache.

In tennis gamers, particularly over a protracted taking part in profession, it’s extra probably that any tear can be a sluggish degeneration that will get aggravated relatively than a sudden, acute tear. Roger Federer and Jo-Wilfried Tsonga are among the many gamers who’ve had surgical procedure on a torn meniscus in the previous few years whereas of their mid-30s, even when the previous was a freak harm whereas operating the tub for his children.

Restoration doesn’t at all times contain surgical procedure. Some folks decide to keep away from surgical procedure – which might produce long-term issues like scarring and arthritis – and recuperate with bodily remedy by build up the muscle groups across the knee. Whether or not that’s an possibility can depend upon the severity of the tear, and even when it’s not, the kind of surgical procedure additionally depends upon the severity of the injury, whether or not acute or constructed up over time.

Djokovic performed by means of the harm in opposition to Francisco Cerundolo (Bertrand Guay / AFP by way of Getty Photos)

American No. 1 Taylor Fritz performed at Wimbledon 23 days after an operation on a meniscus harm, however that was handled with a debridement, which trims the broken part of the meniscus. If Djokovic’s harm is just too extreme for that, a full restore utilizing stitches can be required, which extends the restoration time into months.



Novak Djokovic withdraws from French Open with knee harm

What are Djokovic and his group saying about his harm?

Not a lot. The group was nonetheless absorbing the prognosis and the fact of Djokovic not having the ability to proceed defending his title on Tuesday night and there was no rapid choice about whether or not he would endure surgical procedure.

There may be lingering anger over the choice by event organisers to not take heed to Djokovic’s warnings that the courts have been changing into dangerously slippery due to the fixed rain throughout the previous week after which the short shift to dry circumstances Saturday evening and Monday afternoon when he performed.

About an hour after the event introduced the withdrawal, Djokovic posted on Instagram confirming the character of the harm and added: “My group and I needed to make a troublesome choice after cautious consideration and session.”

When will Djokovic return to tennis?

It’s too early to inform. Meniscus tears differ in severity. Evidently, if Djokovic does seem at Wimbledon on July 1, he probably is not going to be as formidable a power as he has been for greater than a decade when he has solidified his place because the world’s finest grass-court participant.

After Wimbledon, the tennis world’s focus turns to the Olympics on the finish of July, the place Djokovic can be determined to win a first-ever gold medal on the Video games.

What it means for the French Open

What does this imply for the French Open draw?

Djokovic’s withdrawal blows the highest half of the draw extensive open. Casper Ruud, the runner-up for the previous two years, has a bye to the semifinals, the place he’ll play the winner of the quarterfinal between Alexander Zverev and Alex de Minaur. Zverev is trying to attain a fourth straight Roland Garros semifinal, whereas de Minaur had by no means gone past the second spherical right here till this 12 months.

What does this imply for tennis extra extensively?

No matter occurs, there can be a brand new winner of this occasion for the primary time since 2016, when Djokovic gained his first title. Djokovic’s withdrawal additionally extends his tough begin to the 12 months, the place he’s but to succeed in a remaining. It’s the primary time since 2018 that he has entered each of the primary two Grand Slams of the 12 months and gained neither.

It additionally means a brand new ATP Tour world No. 1, with Jannik Sinner assured to take that spot come Monday, June 10, reaching the milestone for the primary time in his profession.

Djokovic’s rating place could tumble additional. He has 1,200 factors to defend at Wimbledon, 1,000 at Cincinnati, and a pair of,000 on the U.S. Open, making for a complete of 4,200. Ought to he not have the ability to compete at these occasions, he’ll lose all his factors from them (along with the 1,600 factors coming off on Monday after his comparatively early exit right here), and his rating could be down at round No. 8 on the planet.

He would then be contact and go to even make November’s ATP Finals for the top-eight gamers of the 12 months and in line for his worst year-end rating since he completed simply exterior the highest 10 in 2017 after an injury-ravaged season.

Two-time dropping finalist Casper Ruud is straight into the semifinals (Dimitar Dilkoff / AFP by way of Getty Photos)

What does this imply for the French Open organisers?

Djokovic pulling out is a nightmare for the French Tennis Federation (FFT).

He blamed the event and “very slippery” courtroom for his harm on Monday and mentioned his group could be chatting with the related occasion workers. The energy of feeling from the Djokovic camp was nonetheless there on Tuesday.

Djokovic’s exit additionally dramatically will increase the probabilities of Zverev being topped the champion on Sunday. Zverev, the No. 4 seed, is defending himself in a courtroom listening to in Berlin over allegations that he abused a former girlfriend throughout an argument in 2020.

In October, the Berlin prison courtroom issued a penalty order, fining him €450,000 ($489,000; £384,000) in reference to the costs from Brenda Patea, a mannequin and social media character who’s the mom of his daughter. Zverev denies the costs. In Germany, a prosecutor can search a penalty order on circumstances it considers easy as a result of there may be compelling proof that it shouldn’t require a trial.



Alexander Zverev is a French Open favourite – whereas his home abuse listening to begins

The defendant has a proper to contest the order, which Zverev has executed. On Friday, the courtroom listening to started in Berlin, which Zverev didn’t should attend. It continued on Monday, with Patea’s testimony given behind closed doorways, and can stick with it throughout a collection of non-consecutive dates this month and subsequent.

In contrast to different league sports activities, the ATP Tour and tennis generally wouldn’t have a proper coverage on home abuse. Zverev profitable one of many greatest prizes within the sport could be an especially uncomfortable state of affairs for the event and the game as a complete.

What do the gamers suppose?

Taking a quarterfinal off the schedule doesn’t actually do a lot good for anybody. For Ruud himself, it means a doubtlessly rhythm-disrupting three days off, whereas for spectators with day tickets for Wednesday, it means they’re a singles match quick. For Zverev and de Minaur, whoever advances to face Ruud could understand themselves to be at an obstacle. A withdrawal at this stage of the event — much like the semifinal withdrawal of Rafael Nadal from Wimbledon in 2022 — instantly invitations questions over sporting integrity.

One resolution could be for Cerundolo, the person Djokovic beat, to be reinstated. The “fortunate loser” already exists in tennis: gamers who lose in qualifying earlier than most important attracts start can stick round on the event venue and nonetheless enter the occasion if a participant within the first spherical withdraws.

This idea hasn’t been utilized to the precise tournaments. When requested concerning the risk, semifinalist Sinner made the argument that’s most frequently introduced in opposition: “He misplaced already, no?”

Though reinstating the twenty third seed would deliver again a match for spectators, and it might be laborious to argue that Cerundolo wouldn’t be a deserving winner if he received by means of three elite gamers, it’s an imperfect resolution. Djokovic, regardless of his harm, beat him truthful and sq. to choose up the rating factors and prize cash connected. In tennis, these are the breaks.

(Prime photograph: Ibrahim Ezzat / NurPhoto by way of Getty Photos)

Leave a Comment