‘Physician Who’ sixtieth Anniversary Is One Massive, Fats Apology to Donna Noble

Photo of author

By Calvin S. Nelson

In all my years overlaying tv, I’ve solely ever as soon as cursed out an interview topic, even in jest.

This was again in 2009, after I was talking with Russell T. Davies in regards to the finish of his tenure as showrunner of Physician Who, and the launch of spinoff miniseries Torchwood: Kids of Earth. Particularly, I had a bone to select concerning the departure of Donna Noble, the blunt, hilarious, endearing companion to David Tenant’s Tenth Physician, performed by Catherine Tate. Donna’s character arc was all about how touring by means of time and area with the Physician opened up her dreary, mundane life in methods she might have by no means imagined. Which made it all of the extra crushing when her story ended with the Physician having to save lots of her life by wiping her recollections of their time collectively — and doing it over Donna’s anguished protests.

As somebody who adored Donna, like practically all of Physician Who fandom, the character of her exit felt too merciless by half. So halfway by means of the Davies interview, I couldn’t resist calling him a bastard for sending her off that means. To Davies’ credit score, he laughed, and even turned to somebody within the room with him to brag, “He simply referred to as me a bastard!”

It’s been 14 years since Davies stepped away from the enduring U.Ok. franchise, which he introduced again from the useless in 2005. Since then, the collection has had some wild swings in high quality. Steven Moffat’s tenure as showrunner began robust with the Matt Smith/Karen Gillan mixture, then started to stumble in its later years. Jodie Whittaker, in the meantime, was an impressed option to play the primary feminine Physician, however she was persistently let down by showrunner Chris Chibnall, who appeared extra within the companions than in Whittaker’s superhumanly curious Physician. 

The collection was in no hazard of vanishing prefer it did between 1989 and the primary Davies season, nevertheless it clearly wanted a course correction. That’s arrived within the type of a deliberate return to the present’s 2000s glory days, with Davies again in cost — and, for the following few weeks, Tenant and Tate again because the Physician and Donna.

And it’s lastly given Davies an opportunity to do proper by Donna Noble.

The reunion started Saturday evening with “The Star Beast,” the primary of three sixtieth anniversary specials — and the start of the franchise’s shift to Disney+. The Physician has inexplicably regenerated with an previous face and character, and as he returns to up to date London, his path retains crossing with Donna, her husband Shaun (Karl Collins), and their teenage daughter Rose (Yasmin Finney). Donna has no thought who this odd man is — although, in typical trend for her, she will be able to’t assist declaring that he’s too previous to get away with carrying the sorts of thin fits he favored in his 30s — and appears conditioned to disregard any hints of alien or timey-wimey exercise. However as Rose(*) discovers an lovable alien referred to as the Meep hiding out in her shed, and because the household is hunted by each a race of bug-like aliens and a workforce of possessed troopers, it turns into unimaginable for Donna to overlook what’s occurring proper in entrance of her face, even when it could value her her life within the discount.

(*) A nod to the primary companion of the fashionable collection, Billie Piper’s Rose Tyler.

On the entire, “The Star Beast” feels very a lot of a bit with the most effective of Davies’ unique run. Its tone, its inclusivity — Rose is trans, and Donna is fiercely protecting of her amid bullying from different neighborhood children, whereas UNIT scientist Shirley (Ruth Madeley) makes use of a wheelchair that may fireplace tranquilizer darts and rockets — and in its choice for emotional resonance over laborious sci-fi. Even after the Physician restores her reminiscence, Donna is ready to survive as a result of her burden is now shared together with her baby, and he or she and Rose in flip can unleash the ability which may kill them just by letting go of it. The extra you concentrate on the mechanics, the sillier it appears, however the energy within the second of seeing Donna’s thoughts restored, and of seeing Rose (an immediately indelible character) assist her save the day, triumphs over the technobabble.

If there’s one space to quibble with, it’s that Donna doesn’t appear indignant sufficient with the Physician as soon as she remembers all the things. She’s upset that his unconscious affect on her impressed her to present away a lot of the lottery winnings he organized for her, however she by no means brings up how terrible it felt to have her thoughts altered in opposition to her will. There are two extra specials to go, although, and loads of time for that if Davies is keen. And Tenant and Tate’s chemistry is as palpable as ever.


There’s a hazard, after all, in Physician Who leaning too laborious into the nostalgia angle. Reunions and revivals are laborious, and characters typically don’t work practically as nicely once they return years later. However this explicit configuration is barely meant to final for these three specials, after which Davies will introduce a brand new Physician, performed by Intercourse Schooling breakout star Ncuti Gatwa. And Davies has accomplished a number of the finest writing of his profession lately, most notable with the 2021 AIDS miniseries It’s a Sin. If he feels he has extra Physician tales in him, then he’s greater than earned the suitable to inform them.

And not less than for now, I retract my “bastard” remark. Whilst I brace myself for the concept he might go to one other unhealthy ending on Donna earlier than we transfer onto the Gatwa period.

Leave a Comment