Sam Bankman-Fried Trial: What to Count on

Photo of author

By Calvin S. Nelson

Last September, Sam Bankman-Fried was described on CNBC because the “Michael Jordan of crypto.” Simply over a 12 months later, on Oct. 3, the founding father of the cryptocurrency trade FTX might be transported from the Metropolitan Detention Middle in Brooklyn, the place he’s at present in custody, to a federal courthouse in Manhattan, for the start of probably the most anticipated prison trials of the 12 months.

Final November, Bankman-Fried’s FTX collapsed following a surprising rush of withdrawals, with the trade unable to account for billions of {dollars} in buyer funds. Federal prosecutors have now charged Bankman-Fried with fraud, conspiracy to commit cash laundering, and several other different counts. 

The trial, which is able to final an estimated six weeks, will seemingly function extremely anticipated testimony from these in Bankman-Fried’s interior circle, who’ve since agreed to cooperate with prosecutors within the case towards him. It’s anticipated to provide a media circus on the extent of the trials of Bernie Madoff and Elizabeth Holmes. 

Right here’s what to know concerning the trial. 

What’s Sam Bankman-Fried charged with?

Bankman-Fried’s FTX was a crypto trade that allowed its customers to purchase, promote and maintain cryptocurrencies, and use monetary mechanisms to wager on these tokens’ value actions. Bankman-Fried informed Congress in a February 2022 listening to that “as a common precept, FTX segregates buyer property from its personal property throughout our platforms.” 

However prosecutors allege that as a substitute of preserving buyer funds siloed, FTX officers loaned these deposits to Alameda Analysis, Bankman-Fried’s hedge fund, on the founder’s route. Prosecutors allege, first, that Bankman-Fried oversaw a technical “backdoor” that allowed him to funnel cash out of FTX buyer accounts undetected—and, second, that he then used these funds to purchase luxurious actual property, donate to political campaigns, and repay Alameda’s lenders. Upon submitting for chapter, FTX owed its prime 50 collectors alone $3.1 billion. Final month, court docket papers filed by Bankman-Fried’s legal professionals stated that he had a “good religion perception” that the best way FTX and Alameda dealt with buyer funds was permitted, Reuters reported. 

In December 2022, Bankman-Fried, 31, was arrested within the Bahamas, the place FTX was primarily based, and extradited to the U.S. He has since pleaded not responsible to all costs and has maintained that, whereas he made errors, he didn’t “knowingly” co-mingle funds. Whereas he faces 13 costs in whole, solely seven of these might be heard throughout this preliminary trial. A separate trial is scheduled for March 2024, which is able to embrace allegations of marketing campaign finance violations.

With a view to convict Bankman-Fried, prosecutors should set up intent: to show that Bankman-Fried willfully lied and misled traders. Moreover, they have to show his guilt “past an inexpensive doubt,” a better normal than in civil instances, and a jury would want to achieve a unanimous verdict for a conviction.

“Intent is all the identify of the sport, and it’s possibly probably the most troublesome aspect for the federal government to show,” says Tim Howard, a companion on the legislation agency Freshfields and a former federal prosecutor with the U.S. Legal professional for the Southern District of New York. “Finally, prosecutors will need to simplify this to: ‘SBF lied to plenty of totally different events to get their cash.’” 

How will the trial unfold?

The quantity of proof that might be thought of throughout this case is staggering. Prosecutors have gathered greater than 6 million pages of paperwork and different data, amounting to one of many largest-ever collections of proof in a white-collar securities fraud case. Bankman-Fried’s Google accounts amounted to 2.5 million pages alone. Prosecutors subpoenaed FTX workers and sought data from the political campaigns that Bankman-Fried contributed to, and are additionally more likely to current audio recordings throughout the trial. All in all, they plan to introduce about 1,300 reveals on the trial.

Along with paperwork, the in-person testimony of Bankman-Fried’s closest associates and collaborators might be essential to the trial’s consequence. Caroline Ellison, who ran Alameda Analysis and dated Bankman-Fried at instances, pleaded responsible to fraud costs and agreed to cooperate with prosecutors towards Bankman-Fried. Their strained relationship has change into central to the trial and its public drama: In July, Bankman-Fried leaked Ellison’s private diary to the New York Occasions, which landed him again in jail after prosecutors accused him of making an attempt to “discredit a witness.” (Bankman-Fried was initially launched on bail in December 2022 and was dwelling at his mother and father’ home in Palo Alto.) Decide Lewis Kaplan agreed with the prosecutors’ arguments, saying throughout his ruling that it appeared unlikely Bankman-Fried would have shared the particularly intimate components of Ellison’s diary “besides to harm, discredit or frighten the topic of the fabric.” 

“My conclusion is there may be possible trigger to consider the defendant tried to tamper with witnesses at the very least twice,” Decide Kaplan declared. (Bankman-Fried reportedly reached out to a second witness over Sign, expressing his need to “have a constructive relationship” and “vet issues with one another.”

Two different prime FTX executives—Gary Wang and Nishad Singh—pleaded responsible to fraud costs. Wang and Singh lived in a penthouse with Bankman-Fried within the Bahamas and had been integral to each his skilled and social life for a few years. A 3rd government, Ryan Salame, pleaded responsible to conspiracy to make illegal political contributions. 

Ellison, Wang and Singh are all now cooperating witnesses—and in the event that they corroborate every others’ tales, it might show damaging to Bankman-Fried’s case. “The truth that he’s received a number of of us within the interior circle who had been most likely in the identical conferences collectively and might doubtlessly testify constantly about issues that had been stated by SBF or to SBF, can doubtlessly be very devastating,” Howard says. 

How will Bankman-Fried defend himself?

Bankman-Fried has handed across the blame for FTX’s failure. He has acknowledged that he made errors and inadequately managed danger on the firm. However he has accused Ellison of being an incompetent investor and of ignoring his steering. He says he was given unhealthy authorized recommendation and was the sufferer of bigger market forces pushing crypto downward. He might additionally try to undermine the credibility of those that will testify towards him. His new legal professionals had been lately granted permission to cross-examine witnesses about their leisure drug use. 

Bankman-Fried will stay in jail at some point of the trial, which means he may have little time to confer together with his legal professionals on the finish of every trial day. As an alternative, he might be allowed to fulfill together with his attorneys at 7 a.m. each morning of trial dates. His legal professionals have claimed that he has been subsisting totally on bread and water whereas in jail. 

It’s but unclear whether or not Bankman-Fried himself will take the stand. He has embraced talking alternatives up to now: he invited reporters to his residence even whereas on house-arrest. There may be precedent for high-profile defendants testifying. Disgraced Theranos founder Holmes took the stand in her personal federal fraud trial, making an attempt to make an emotional attraction to the jury. 

Howard says {that a} defendant like Bankman-Fried selecting to testify comes with benefits but in addition “important peril.” 

“It’s very highly effective for the defendant to look the jury within the eye and clarify what was happening in his thoughts,” he says. “However when you’re a defendant on the stand, as you noticed with Elizabeth Holmes, I’d count on a prolonged, pointed cross-examination that can undergo each assertion he’s made and attempt to make him look foolish and like a liar.”

Howard predicts that Bankman-Fried’s legal professionals would solely put him on the stand as a last-minute contingency. “I think they’ll see how the federal government’s proof is available in; how effectively they’re in a position to assault the credibility of the cooperators; the physique language of the jury once they react to the cooperators–and make a strategic gametime resolution,” he says. 

What are the stakes?

Bankman-Fried faces a most sentence of 115 years. However some legal professionals suppose that even when convicted, his precise jail time could be far much less, as a result of lots of the costs are related in nature. Decide Kaplan has full discretion; he might elect to make the costs concurrent versus consecutive, says Howard. 

Whereas a single man might be on trial, the entire crypto trade might be within the harsh highlight. Many crypto insiders have argued that Bankman-Fried’s alleged crimes have nothing to do with crypto in any respect: That he’s charged with finishing up old-school fraud within the vein of Bernie Madoff. However Bankman-Fried was the crypto trade’s American figurehead; he portrayed himself because the accountable steward of an unruly trade rife with scams. 

The trial will draw public consideration as soon as extra to crypto crimes at a time when the trade desperately needs to maneuver on. Bankman-Fried has blamed others within the crypto trade, most notably Changpeng Zhao, the CEO of rival trade Binance, for FTX’s failures—and the entire spectacle might additional problem the trade. “With all the general public consideration on the cash that’s been misplaced, you will principally encourage Congress and regulators to be extra aggressive towards all the ecosystem,” Howard says. 
The courtroom drama will seemingly additionally function fodder for a really keen Hollywood. A slew of productions about Bankman-Fried are already in growth, together with an Apple adaptation of Michael Lewis’ ebook Going Infinite and an Amazon Prime drama collection from the Russo Brothers.

Leave a Comment