Tillie Cole’s ‘Darkness Embraced’ Darkish Romance Sparks Debate on TikTok

Photo of author

By Calvin S. Nelson

When 27-year-old BookTok creator Sat posted a TikTok criticizing a darkish romance guide for what she known as “romanticizing” the Ku Klux Klan, she thought the video would spark a dialog about racism in guide publishing. However even after the writer, Tillie Cole, eliminated the guide, Sat and at the very least two different BookTok creators inform Rolling Stone that after publicly criticizing the guide, they had been targets of a coordinated harassment marketing campaign on TikTok. 

“I wished to carry it to of us’ consideration as a result of I believed possibly different individuals don’t know,” Sat tells Rolling Stone. “However [Tille Cole fans] have this concept that as a result of they learn the guide, they usually actually favored it, they’ll then goal not solely me, however different BIPOC individuals who had been talking out about this guide. Our feedback have been stuffed with harassment and mass reporting.”

Cole is a well-liked romance novelist on TikTok, the place her guide A Thousand Boy Kisses is a staple within the BookTok group. Content material associated to it has 149 million views on TikTok and Cole is an lively consumer there, interacting with followers and posting movies for her 76,000 followers. However in her self-published erotica sequence Hades Hangmen, the 2019 guide Darkness Embraced options fictional essential character Tanner Ayers, inheritor to the Texas Ku Klux Klan. When Tanner meets Adelita Quintana, the daughter of “probably the most brutal cartel boss in Mexico,” the 2 are on the spot enemies, however ultimately fall in love, solely to be thrust into the center of a struggle between Adelita’s household, the KKK, and the Hades Hangmen, Tanner’s fictional bike gang. Amazon and Goodreads descriptions of the guide embody the tagline “The deepest love might be born from the fiercest hate.” Cole didn’t reply to a number of requests for remark, however on her private social media accounts, she posted a press release saying the sequence can be eliminated and he or she can be taking a break. “I’m at all times studying as an writer and have taken this to coronary heart and will likely be aware of all my tales going ahead,” Cole mentioned. “I endeavor to alway attempt to do higher.”

The guide is a part of a subgenre known as darkish romance, which regularly embody taboo themes, mature content material, and questionable morality. Many common books on this style make use of tropes like enemies-to-lovers, and introduce essential characters with questionable priorities and occupations like bike gangs, drug sellers, cartel operators, or kidnappers who then fall in love. Sat is says she is a fan of darkish romance, however she and dozens of different creators say that Cole’s guide does a disservice to darkish romance readers by utilizing racism and white supremacy as taboo, with out doing any underlying work to discover why the group or its beliefs are so harmful. 

“It was extremely gross to me that of all of the issues that might have been made up on this fictional guide, this one that just isn’t even American thought that the Ku Klux Klan was the right group to tug a love curiosity from,” Sat tells Rolling Stone. “And it’s particularly upsetting to me as a Black American girl from the south whose elders and household have been brutalized, terrorized, and traumatized by the KKK.” 

In a number of movies on TikTok, Sat criticized Cole’s guide and its common opinions on Goodreads, particularly across the dialogue and scenes she known as a “romanticization” of the Southern terror group and its members. Whereas at the very least one was flagged and deleted, the followups had been considered over 600,000 occasions and sparked quite a few response movies from different guide creators criticizing the sequence and its reputation on TikTok.

However within the wake of Cole’s apology, a focused harassment marketing campaign from her followers has continued. Cole followers have argued that whereas Darkness Embraced does closely function the KKK, it doesn’t romanticize it as a result of Tanner ultimately decides to go away. Some have additionally known as Sat’s feedback an try at censorship. Earlier than the feedback on Cole’s apology posts had been turned off, they had been full of a majority of followers telling the writer she had nothing to apologize for, and the pushback was an try at cancel tradition.

Along with Sat, BookTok creators Lo Morales and Jessica Arrieta inform Rolling Stone that once they spoke out in opposition to different parts of Cole’s guide, together with the inclusion of slurs and racist dialogue, they acquired lots of of feedback claiming they had been attempting to destroy Cole’s profession and a beloved novel.

“This isn’t a illustration of the entire style of darkish romance. I’m an enormous lover of darkish romance,” Morales says. “However I feel that using racism as a trope, particularly by someone who won’t ever really feel the results of it, is unacceptable. And this isn’t an unusual incidence when Black and brown girls converse out about content material in books. I’ve a filter on my feedback for particular phrases and all of them are slurs. As a result of I realized in a short time how comfy persons are at utilizing them on the web.”

Arrieta provides that in now-private Fb teams for each romance readers and Cole followers particularly, readers had been inspired to harass and mass report creators who spoke out in regards to the Cole guide. In screenshots reviewed by Rolling Stone, separate teams included a number of calls to report Sat’s video till it was faraway from TikTok, in addition to give 5-star opinions to Cole’s different novels to counteract the backlash. 


Whereas followers of the writer have continued to push again in opposition to the criticism, together with persevering with to report Sat’s movies, the creator tells Rolling Stone she’s extra emboldened than ever to proceed sharing her opinions and views on common BookTok works. 

“Individuals have company. Individuals are going to jot down what they wish to. I’m not right here to inform individuals what they’ll and can’t write,” Sat says. “I’m right here to ask them ought to they be writing that story? And I feel extra individuals ought to ask themselves that.”

Leave a Comment